Site Selection Brief, Farm & Home Store
Winthrop Harbor Is Farm Store Country
831 Sheridan Rd, Winthrop Harbor, IL 60096, Illinois-Wisconsin Border Corridor
Esri consumer spending data, psychographic profiles, and Tapestry segmentation confirm a high-fit trade area for a farm and home retail destination serving pet owners, homeowners, hobbyists, boaters, and rural lifestyle consumers
The Customers Are Already Here. The Store Is Not.
Winthrop Harbor and its surrounding Illinois-Wisconsin corridor is a textbook farm and home store trade area: high homeownership, strong pet ownership, active outdoor recreation, robust lawn and garden spending, and a "Buy American" psychographic that indexes 9 percent above the national norm. The 5-minute trade area is dominated by Tapestry segments "Room to Roam" (33.2%) and "Classic Comfort" (29.1%), exactly the rural lifestyle, owner-occupied, self-reliant consumer profiles that anchor Blain's Farm & Fleet, Rural King, and Tractor Supply stores across the Midwest. Within 15 minutes, there are 47,109 households spending an estimated $28M on lawn and garden, $22M on pets, $185M on home maintenance and remodeling, and $7.8M on recreational vehicles and boats, the core product categories of every farm and home store format. No Blain's. No Rural King. No Tractor Supply. No FS Farm & Home. No Big R. The market gap is wide open.
Esri Trade Area Demographics, 831 Sheridan Rd
| Metric | 5-Minute | 10-Minute | 15-Minute |
|---|---|---|---|
| Population (2025) | 11,989 | 52,138 | 120,460 |
| Households | 4,664 | 19,420 | 46,637 |
| Homeownership | 75.2% | 68.9% | 65.8% |
| Median household income | $86,333 | $79,356 | $80,641 |
| 2030 income forecast | $103,395 | $90,057 | $92,196 |
| Median home value | $241,333 | $238,014 | $242,601 |
| Households with pets | 56.6% (MPI 110) | 52.7% (MPI 102) | 52.2% (MPI 101) |
Core Farm & Home Spending Categories, 15-Minute Ring
Home Maintenance and Remodeling Services
Lawn and Garden, supplies, equipment, care
Pets, food, supplies, veterinary, accessories
Recreational Vehicles and Fees, including marina
Building Material and Garden Supply Dealers (NAICS 444)
Home Maintenance and Remodeling Materials
Major Appliances, 15-minute ring
Sports, Recreation and Exercise Equipment
Key Spending Categories, SPI vs U.S. Average, 5-Minute Ring
Spending Potential Index versus U.S. average (100) for categories most relevant to farm and home retail. Esri 2025, 831 Sheridan Rd, Winthrop Harbor, IL, 4,664 households.
| Category | Value | Index |
|---|---|---|
| Home improvement activity (households) | 37.2% of HHs | MPI 110 |
| Households own pets | 56.6% of HHs | MPI 110 |
| Property taxes (owned homes) | SPI 112 | 12% above average |
| Homeowners insurance | SPI 114 | 14% above average |
| Lawn and garden (household operations) | SPI 107 | 7% above average |
| Maintenance and remodeling materials | SPI 112 | 12% above average |
| Large appliance purchase (households) | 19.2% of HHs | MPI 107 |
| Power tools | SPI 107 | 7% above average |
| Hand tools | SPI 106 | 6% above average |
| Building material and garden supply (NAICS 444) | SPI 110 | 10% above average |
Esri Tapestry Lifestyle Segments, Who Lives Here
Room to Roam (K7)
33.2%The dominant segment in the 5-minute ring. Rural homeowners who value self-sufficiency, outdoor recreation, pets, and practical home goods. They own property, fix things themselves, and shop for tools, livestock supplies, sporting goods, and work apparel, the core Blain's and Rural King customer.
Classic Comfort (K4)
29.1%Established homeowners in stable suburban-rural settings. Value quality, durability, and trusted brands. Strong lawn and garden, home improvement, pet supply, and major appliance spenders. The anchor of any farm and home store's loyalty base, repeat customers who come back weekly.
Middle Ground (K2)
16.1%Middle-income homeowning families balancing practicality and value. Spend on kids' supplies, pet care, household basics, and seasonal goods. Price-conscious but brand-loyal once trust is established, ideal for store-brand and private-label farm store products.
Family Bonds (E6)
11.3%Multigenerational family households with strong community ties and traditional values. Pet owners, home gardeners, and recreational buyers. High spend on children's and family goods, and strong loyalty to stores that reflect their values, especially those that emphasize American-made products.
North Point Marina Visitor
800K/yrNot a Tapestry segment, a real traffic opportunity. Boaters, anglers, and marina visitors who need bait, tackle, marine supplies, work clothing, coolers, and outdoor gear. No farm and home store currently serves them on the Sheridan Road approach. A Winthrop Harbor location captures this entire demand layer.
"Buy American" Index
MPI 109Adults in the 5-minute ring who completely agree that buying American is important score 9 percent above the national average. This psychographic is a direct match for the brand identity of Blain's Farm & Fleet and Rural King, both of which feature American-made products prominently.
Farm & Home Store Brand Profiles
Blain's Farm & Fleet
The Modern General Store. Wisconsin-based. Closest brand to this market.
Founded in 1955 in Janesville, Wisconsin, Blain's is a family-owned regional icon across WI, IL, IA, and MI. Their nearest stores to this site are in Sturtevant, WI and Elgin, IL, both 35+ minutes away, leaving a clear gap in the north Lake County / Kenosha corridor. Blain's explicitly seeks markets with homeowners, families, hobby farmers, and rural shoppers, an exact description of the Winthrop Harbor trade area's dominant Tapestry segments.
| Total U.S. locations | 45+ |
| States served | WI, IL, IA, MI |
| Typical square feet | 100,000 to 120,000 |
| Founded | 1955, family-owned, Janesville, WI |
Rural King
America's Farm & Home Store. 135 locations. Northward expansion underway.
Founded in 1960 in Mattoon, IL, Rural King has grown to 135 stores across 13 states and surpassed $1 billion in annual sales in 2015. The chain's Illinois footprint is concentrated downstate. There are no Rural King locations in Lake County or northern Illinois. The brand sells work clothing, livestock and equine supplies, firearms, hunting and fishing gear, lawn and garden, fencing, power tools, and farm chemicals. Free coffee and popcorn, and pets welcome in-store, drive traffic and loyalty.
| U.S. locations (2024) | 135 |
| Annual sales (2015 and later) | $1B+ |
| Typical square feet | 100,000 |
| Founded | Mattoon, IL, 1960 |
Tractor Supply Company
NASDAQ: TSCO. 2,296+ locations. 90 new stores per year target.
America's largest rural lifestyle retailer with 2,296 locations as of fiscal 2024 and an announced target of 3,000 U.S. stores. The company opens approximately 90 new locations per year and is actively expanding in suburban markets. The average transaction value is $60 to $63. The "Life Out Here" strategy targets homeowners with land, pet owners, equine enthusiasts, and hobby farmers, all strong segments in this trade area. TSC's nearest northern Illinois locations are in Waukegan and Grayslake.
| Locations, fiscal 2024 | 2,296+ |
| Long-term store target | 3,000 |
| New store annual target | 90 per year |
| Typical square feet | 19,000 |
FS Farm & Home / Big R Stores
Regional Midwest farm co-ops and independent farm store formats.
FS Farm & Home (operated by Growmark's FS member co-ops) and Big R Stores serve the Illinois and Wisconsin agricultural corridor with farm inputs, hardware, work clothing, and home goods. These formats are typically smaller (20,000 to 50,000 square feet) and more agronomy-focused, but serve a loyal rural customer base. Both formats have existing relationships with Illinois farm bureau and cooperative networks, giving them a built-in customer acquisition channel if they open in northern Lake County.
| Core market | IL / WI |
| Typical square feet | 20,000 to 50,000 |
| Model | Co-op, member-owned |
| Product mix | Farm inputs plus hardware, clothing, home |
Brand Comparison, Site Fit for Winthrop Harbor
| Site Fit Factor | Blain's Farm & Fleet | Rural King | Tractor Supply | FS / Big R |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Market presence in WI/IL corridor | Strong | IL-based | Active expansion | IL/WI co-ops |
| No existing location within 20 miles | Gap confirmed | Gap confirmed | Nearest: 12 miles | Gap confirmed |
| Fits "Room to Roam" Tapestry segment | Excellent fit | Excellent fit | Strong fit | Good fit |
| Pet supply category (MPI 110 trade area) | Core category | Core category | Core category | Limited |
| Sporting goods / hunting / fishing | Includes licenses | Firearms plus licenses | Limited | Limited |
| Marina / boating accessories | Relevant SKUs | Partial | Partial | Limited |
| Typical store size | 100,000 to 120,000 sq ft | 100,000 sq ft | 19,000 sq ft | 20,000 to 50,000 sq ft |
| Franchise / independent entry possible | Family-owned | Corporate | Corporate | Co-op model |
| Automotive service center | Yes | No | No | No |
| Overall trade area fit score | 5 stars | 4.5 stars | 4 stars | 3 stars |
Key Investor Insights
75.2% homeownership in the 5-minute ring, farm store's best customer
Farm and home stores thrive on homeowners, people with yards, garages, sheds, and land who buy tools, hardware, lawn equipment, paint, and seasonal goods throughout the year. The 5-minute trade area's 75.2% homeownership rate is significantly above the U.S. norm and defines the core farm store customer base.
56.6% of households own pets, MPI 110 in the 5-minute ring
Pet supplies are one of the fastest-growing and highest-margin categories in the farm store format. More than half of all households in the immediate trade area own a pet, with the MPI 10 percent above the national average. Cats (MPI 114) and dogs (MPI 112) both exceed the U.S. norm, supporting robust food, treat, care, and accessory sales year-round.
SPI 110 on building materials, $59.5M in 15-minute retail demand
The NAICS 444 "Building Material & Garden Equipment & Supplies Dealers" category scores SPI 110 in the 5-minute ring and represents $59.5M in annual retail demand across the 15-minute trade area, all of which currently travels to Waukegan, Zion, or other corridors. A farm and home store here would capture a significant share of that demand at source.
$28M in lawn and garden spending within 15 minutes
Lawn and garden is a flagship category for every farm store format: seasonal, high-ticket, and repeat-visit-driving. The 15-minute trade area spends $28M annually on lawn and garden, growing to $31.5M by 2030. Combined with the high homeownership rate, this category alone justifies serious site evaluation.
800,000 marina visitors create a specialty outdoor retail demand spike
North Point Marina's 800,000 annual visitors, boaters, anglers, and charter clients, need bait, tackle, marine oils, coolers, work boots, outdoor apparel, and dock supplies. Blain's Farm & Fleet in particular stocks all of these categories. A Winthrop Harbor location on the Sheridan Road approach intercepts every marina-bound vehicle with no competing farm store anywhere in the corridor.
MPI 109 "Buying American", the farm store customer's core value
Adults in the 5-minute ring who completely agree that buying American is important score 9 percent above the U.S. average (MPI 109). This is not a demographic, it is a values profile that precisely matches the brand positioning of Blain's Farm & Fleet and Rural King, both of which feature American-made products and have deep Midwest community roots.
Power tools SPI 107, hand tools SPI 106, above-average tool buyers
The 5-minute ring over-indexes on both power tools (SPI 107) and hand tools (SPI 106), two of the highest-margin, highest-attach-rate categories in the farm store format. Combined with home improvement activity at MPI 110, the trade area is populated by active DIYers who visit hardware aisles frequently.
Household income rising 20% by 2030, growing into premium categories
Median household income in the 5-minute ring is forecast to grow from $86,333 in 2025 to $103,395 by 2030, a 20 percent increase. Rising income supports premiumization in all farm store categories: from store-brand pet food to branded riding mowers, from basic work clothing to premium hunting and fishing gear.
A Trade Area Built for Farm & Home Retail. No Competitor Has Arrived Yet.
Winthrop Harbor's Illinois-Wisconsin Lake Corridor offers a demographic and psychographic profile that farm and home store brands spend years searching for: high homeownership, strong pet ownership, active outdoor recreation, proven tool and lawn and garden spending, and a consumer base that values American-made products and community-rooted retail. With 47,109 households within 15 minutes, 800,000 annual marina visitors, and zero competing farm and home stores in the immediate market, the first brand to arrive establishes category leadership in one of the most underserved farm store corridors in the greater Chicagoland region.
Contact Economic Development
Village of Winthrop Harbor — Economic Development
830 Sheridan Road, Winthrop Harbor, IL 60096 · www.investintheharbor.com
Connect with us on social media for updates on development opportunities in Winthrop Harbor
Data sources: Esri House & Home Expenditures Report. Esri Retail Demand by Industry Report. Esri Retail Demand Outlook Report. Esri Retail Goods & Services Expenditures Report. Esri Retail Market Potential Report. All reports: 831 Sheridan Rd, Winthrop Harbor, IL 60096. Drive time radii 5, 10 and 15 minutes. 2025 and 2030 projections. MPI (Market Potential Index) and SPI (Spending Potential Index) benchmarked against U.S. average (100). Consumer Expenditure Survey data: BLS 2022 to 2023. Esri Tapestry Segmentation copyright 2026 Esri. Brand data: Blain's Farm & Fleet (farmandfleet.com, Wikipedia), Rural King (ruralking.com, Wikipedia), Tractor Supply Company (SEC 10-K FY2024, NASDAQ: TSCO), Tractor Supply Q4 2024 earnings release.